>>7223I would never believe anything that is well known in the fanbase, after all, things that are supposed well-known in the fanbase is why you couldn't talk about Eva even prior to the final film. People say a lot of things in interviews as well and I don't believe a single one of them. This also parallels the experience of talking about Eva very nicely, "but Anno said in an interview once", I don't care, Anno has said a lot of things. Same principle applies here.
>However, in the film we've only see 5 timelines (4 time loops). So if we go with the "only what is shown in the film counts" idea, then Homura's total loop time is about 6 months.That is not correct at all. This might be confusing, but just because something isn't shown, doesn't mean it didn't happen. It is clear that a lot of time passed, because Homura changes quite a lot as she keeps trying.
I'd have gone with Rebellion being the 15th attempt by the way, based on another piece of side material, hypocritical as it may be. But it's technically also in the film, so it's fine.
I guess I was off the mark with your intentions, after all.
>karmic destiny and madoka's power growth>the canon status of spin offs I wouldn't really consider these to be too important, because neither of these things is significant in the context of Rebellion or Madoka as a whole.