[ home / bans / all ] [ qa / jp / sum ] [ maho ] [ f / ec ] [ b / poll ] [ tv / bann ] [ toggle-new ]

/qa/ - Questions and Answers

Questions and Answers about QA

New Reply

Options
Comment
File
Whitelist Token
Spoiler
Password (For file deletion.)
Markup tags exist for bold, itallics, header, spoiler etc. as listed in " [options] > View Formatting "


[Return] [Bottom] [Catalog]

File:6ff501b2df4036555382e21856….jpg (870.34 KB,1600x1146)

 No.143543

this thread is for chinese media, entertainment, 2d cultural stuff and probably information regarding the language.

a goal is to spread interest in chinese culture and media similar to how /jp/a/ and 4chan spread interest in otaku culture. i'm pretty much the only person on earth who wants this so we'll play it by ear and see what interest others have in it.

post questions or other feelings if you feel like it. i'd prefer to not have political stuff instead focus on the 2d cultural stuff so music, donghua(anime), manhua(manga), and webnovels. other chinese stuff welcome too i guess.

 No.143546

File:22d311376dbf9ac01210d536a1….mp4 (1.57 MB,1920x1080)


 No.143547

File:9002fc58184bb9a78d804a5776….jpg (1.49 MB,2304x3072)

I've been sloughing my way through God and Devil World, I actually like it, bit autistic at times, don't really know why people call it bad...

 No.143553

I'm a fan of LoGH and want to read Romance of the Three Kingdoms. What's the best English translation?

 No.143561

File:49fd2dfe00290bce8b9a2a2fd5….jpg (112.48 KB,766x1024)

I don't really have anything to add or ask at the moment. I'm currently learning Chinese. It's a rather nice language that's not overly complex and tones aren't so bad onces you learn pinyin. My Chinese Professor is interesting to listen to. She has a lot of stories, of being a teacher in China, and being a reporter. It always makes me laugh when she describes how to write a new character being introduced. Pretty often she makes it a point to say "don't write it like this... this is ugly, like Japanese". Typically she's talking about having non-straight lines like in 月 when writing other characters, and to extend the hook in characters like 我, and to trail off in pressure when making the other leg in 人. Grammar isn't too bad either. It's more or less like English just with word order moved around in certain cases.

 No.143568

>>143464
>>143514
Awesome. Thanks, dude.

>are you really interested in learning it or it's just a kinda passing thing?
I think I'm not as interested as I was in Japanese... I mean, otherwise I would've already learned it, of course. There are a few different reasons I'd like to learn it. First off, my initial motivation for Japanese was JP media, and it paid off majorly, but over time I grew interested in the language itself too, things like kanji, etymology, 故事/諺 and so on are intrinsically linked to Chinese language/history/culture, so I feel learning Chinese would give me a much better understanding of Japanese. Also, I've noticed there are a lot of good piracy resources for JP stuff on the CN side of the internet. Not too long ago someone in the 4/jp/ VN thread linked a Chinese FTP with pretty much every single commercial VN ever released, for example. I'd like to gain access to these because I pretty often am unable to find raws for manga I want to read.

As for CN content itself, that's probably the biggest obstacle for me because I just don't know anything about that stuff. There's a few things I'm interested in, like the 90s TV adaptation of RotTK and some classical poetry like Li Bai, but that probably requires a pretty high level. I assume there must be interesting modern 2D content out there, I'm just not exposed to it. For Japanese stuff, I grew up watching shows like DBZ, Gundam Wing and YYH on TV, and playing Pokemon and Final Fantasy, so transitioning into other JP content and then later the language itself was a pretty natural process, but Chinese stuff I'm totally clueless about. I guess from what you said you had a similar experience, and only really got into CN 2D stuff after you started learning the language?

 No.143577

File:d6292a3c78ed12bd0b3590de9f….png (246.84 KB,600x600)

>>143568
>I feel learning Chinese would give me a much better understanding of Japanese
Just from my brief studying Chinese, I've definitely noticed a lot of words I know from Japanese and their Chinese origins. The pronunciation is often a bit shifted because the words were imported a long time ago. I think I read that pronunciation is often closer to Cantonese than it is to Mandarin/Putonghua.

 No.143579

File:3f179520caaf4562d9f929a33d….jpg (16.71 MB,7046x4450)

>>143553
i have absolutely no idea.
>>143547
that's pretty retro it's an older series. have you read other stuff like dao of bizzare immortal, ten days ultimatum, and reverend insanity? these aren't the traditional battle style ones instead they focus more on intrigue and bizarre stuff.
>>143561
have you tried these ai like deepseek to practice with and learn from? what about media you use to listen or watch.

https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1cK41117mP/
https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1Co4y1L77t/
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kY_Or_S_7yk

>>143568
i decided to learn chinese to read web novels since they weren't getting translated fast enough and mtl was shit. i had no idea what the language even really sounded like cause i had never even watched a movie with mandarin or anything else. finding stuff to read to practice was never a struggle or concern but finding stuff to listen to and watch was difficult since i had no idea what i even liked or where to find it. bilibili is the best place for chinese 2d cultural stuff.

i have no idea what kinds of music or media others would like so i can only toss out random stuff and see if you like any of it.

https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1d14y1o7JZ/

did anybody listen to the other songs i link and like any of them or they're off to your ears

https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV16iDUYgEUK/
https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV14XpgeZEo7
https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV13PrrY2EBN
https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1gWCrYDE6i
https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1bE41117XL/
https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1FDgGe9Ebh/
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xeqbnEB_6Lo
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P0V_xAee-Rk
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G9GbYf0RKQg

 No.143583

File:832fb4f50baf6b1a2dc927e7a1….jpg (57.48 KB,857x770)

https://www.bilibili.com/guochuang
not all but most of the quality donghua from china
https://anidb.net/tag/6152/animetb/?cat.minweight=0&h=1&noalias=1&orderby.airdate=0.2&orderby.name=1.1
https://anilist.co/search/anime?countryOfOrigin=CN&sort=START_DATE_DESC
these list them based on when they aired.

i think a number of these have english subs and you can find them on nyaa or just youtube the name. for a while i was just typing 动画 and grabbing stuff there's a lot of choice now or rips people put onto youtube.

 No.143584

File:Screenshot 2025-04-15 at 2….png (228.83 KB,446x579)

>>143579
>have you tried these ai like deepseek to practice with and learn from? what about media you use to listen or watch.
I'm learning in a classroom setting, so it's a bit different. Mostly learning new vocabulary weekly, practicing speaking in pairs, submitting speaking work and writing for the professor (native Chinese) to grade, and doing practice work like grammar work and reading comprehension. An interesting thing I found helpful recently was using Whisper to check my pronunciation before submitting some speaking homework recently.

I'm just a beginner, so media is a bit beyond me. The extent of my ability is composing and understanding simple sentences like "我很喜欢这个饭"

This is the textbook my class uses if you're curious at all. https://cheng-tsui.publishercart.com/3d-flip-book/integrated-chinese-4th-edition-with-supplemental-readings-sampler/

 No.143595

File:807a70c4308be3e7206ade2a88….jpg (9.79 MB,7075x3598)

>>143546
this is what 粤语/cantonese sounds like https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1mz4y1M7a6

>>143584
my brain can't learn in a class like that i actually just have to grind my nose on it like a dog. for a normal functioning human i don't really have any advice. do you like any of the music i linked or you didn't even waste time listening?

 No.143620

>>143595
>do you like any of the music i linked
I liked this one:
>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kY_Or_S_7yk
But it's not the sort of stuff I would pick out to listen to. Japanese sounds nicer to my ears, but I mostly listen to instrumental music.

Also... maybe I'm just weird, but I actually like more traditional music. Stuff like https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UFQkmCDa93o

A couple years ago I also took an interest in the drama 秦香莲 after that one Chinese Tom and Jerry meme took off a few years ago >>>/aut/1733, but I haven't watched any since. This was a few years before I started learning Chinese. I only started this year so my knowledge of Chinese media is pretty much limited to whatever goes viral on the English-speaking internet.

 No.143629

I don't have much to add except that sinic 2d culture does look underexplored to me.
I love going on bilibili and just watching random things from the little I can gather from knowing japanese (not the other poster, to clarify) and some grammar I learned out of pure linguistic/cultural interest. I also enjoy listening to mandarin covers, vocaloid or otherwise. Reminds me of niconico in a sense, except not dying.
They seem to have a very interesting creative culture going around that is just not known on this side of this firewall.
And they make good art - Weibo is a good tag to use on boorus.
I wish to learn mandarin eventually.

https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1NN411D7hg/

 No.143764

File:ef4d1254e347b67118cd0b1d2e….png (10.84 MB,2894x4093)

>>143620
music is difficult cause everybody has their own taste and wants to hear different stuff. even more so cause mandarin sounds so foreign to everybody. for traditional music i like them with a more modern style filled with energy instead of the slower pace of the more purely traditional songs.

https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1ee4y1z7zx
https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1c3411b7k7 (祖娅纳惜)
here's a slower one
https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1Q8411b7HS (祖娅纳惜)
the singer for these two songs does a lot of traditional stuff

this is traditional style, but for mongolia
https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1F94y1M7yv/

that style is called 中国风 if you want to link random videos that catch your eye and listen
https://search.bilibili.com/all?keyword=中国风
here's the first link for it for example https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1bvfbYUE3q

bonus strange traditional/folk style
https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV18GkPYzEkD


i like piano and violin a lot so here's one for that
https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1gM411Z7SU


here's a vtuber singing the popular songs of 2024 synced up blending them together
https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV13pkdY9Ey2

>>143629
i like covers too especially of japanese songs where they sing in mandarin. the popular streamers/singers all seem to know japanese so they just sang it in japanese like 5 years ago but now they a couple covers with mandarin and there.

https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1tF41137H5
https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1gM4y1a7bv
https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1Dh411E71m this is a bit japanese but primarily mandarin

中文版翻唱
shows them but they don't always label them and most of them are korean songs cause it's popular for them to do mandarin version of kpop songs not as much for japanese stuff.

i like this song
https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1uM411F75Q
https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1A8411L74p
the two vtubers sang it together
https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1f6PdeoEvt



hanakana the japanese voice actress singing mandarin. i don't know why or how but she learned mandarin and sings mandarin songs and has went onto the biggest chinese new years special singing them for a couple years now. she's my favorite japanese voice actress so i'm glad she sees the light.
https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1qY411G7G4




i should probably make a more organized helpful post with stuff about pronunciation and grammar. i need a 3-4+ days though cause it's tiring and isn't as easy as listening to music i have to spend time thinking about it. ai stuff like deepseek really made all the resources i saved pretty useless. i don't know if somebody made anki decks with good ai voice over for them cause i haven't looked, but probably? i mean that's one of the best use for it.

 No.143775

>>143629
>And they make good art - Weibo is a good tag to use on boorus.
They post a lot of great stuff on lofter too.
Kinda burns me up when I think of how much art never makes it here. Danbooru only hosts images that the uploaders find worthy of reuploading, and it's often the case that a certain artist only has artworks pertaining to popular gacha and tubers while their original (and often more ambitious) works remain mirrored.

 No.143788

A while ago I found this video that puts local music to provinces in China. I like quite a few of the songs.

>>143764
>https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1c3411b7k7
I think I may have parts of this song before, but I can't remember where. It sounds familiar to me.

>https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1gM411Z7SU
>https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1Q8411b7HS
These are both really nice.

>https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV13pkdY9Ey2
This one is pretty cool. Sounds a bit autotuned, but I'm not sure if that's from the from the song switching?

>https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1f6PdeoEvt/
Pretty

 No.143791

>>143764
>here's a slower one
https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1Q8411b7HS (祖娅纳惜)
i posted the wrong link here's the correct one
https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV194411y7tE/
this singer is actually 祖娅纳惜 in the correct link. the other link has 阿蕊娅Aria who also does chinese style stuff like https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1YcXeYREMH but also sings in english,russian,and opera styles

 No.143804

>>143788
>This one is pretty cool. Sounds a bit autotuned, but I'm not sure if that's from the from the song switching?
i'm not really sure how they did it. i posted it cause it's a compilation of the popular songs of 2024 that kept trending on bilibili and had a lot of people making covers. i forgot to mention if you heard any portions you like and take a screenshot or say timeframe of the song with the the frame and i'll link you the original song for it. the frame in the middle shows the song it's playing for each switch.

maybe a compilation like this is useful?
https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1RgNEe2E2v/ it's 117 songs
sometimes i just listen to find songs i like similar to this one
https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1hV411e7Ps/

they post wojak stuff on bilibili along with country ball memes. i don't really follow any of it though just see it appear sometimes when browsing.

 No.143807

>>143804
I'm surprised wojaks and country balls are still a thing in lazy youtube thumbnails when AI is around. Sure, it still looks low effort but at least it looks slightly more topical.

 No.143896

So I was curious about Ne Zha since the sequel became the highest grossing animated film of all time if I'm not mistaken. My first step was watching this old film Ne Zha Conquers the Dragon King on Youtube:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xxa72iEZkfk
A really nice watch, I specially like the artstyle imitating old chinese paintings. However since I'm pretty much new to chinese culture there was a missing context and background on characters, motives and powers. Nevertheless a very nice watch, would recomend to anyone interesed in chinese culture.

Then I proceed with Ne Zha (2019), it wasn't easy to find an online version with both good quality and English subs but I settled for a Torrent and I really enjoyed it. Felt like a battle shonen but I like the fact there's no "villain" in the common sense, the antagonists have their own motives they explain clearly unlike in the previous Ne Zha I saw. Even the "bad guy" had a pretty good reason for doing what he did albeit I don't quite understand his character. Can't explain without spoiling the film. It was funny at times too, chinese humor isn't that different from japanese humor. It's a movie for kids so the violence isn't hardcore or anything but the final battle was kinda epic.
I wish I could find a good rip of the sequel but seems like it hasn't been uploaded to the internet yet.

 No.144029

File:8ee7096bc0a0cc2d50d06439f4….jpg (62.47 KB,512x382)

I live in Hong Kong but, embarrassingly, I don't speak any Cantonese (or Mandarin for that matter) and I've only seen one Bruce Lee movie.
I feel like I could be more invested in the place I'm calling home for the next few years.

 No.144030

OP, whats the appeal of chinese 2D media? like... is it on par with japanese stuff, does it have cool+cute lolis, do chinese teens have their own equivalent of chuuni, are there gonna be more games like little witch nobeta?
i really dont like the sound of chinese speech

 No.144033

>>144030
Not OP and I don't know anything about Chinese media, but I assume there has to be a good amount of chuuni. After all, kanji is an essential part of chuunidom.

 No.144052

>>144030
Ne Zha is very chuuni and Wukong was the first shonen protagonist. About cute girls I think they copy the japanese style more. I don't play gacha but you know those like Genshin or ZZZ have cute girl (I think).

 No.144088

My favorite part of modern Chinese culture media has to be the cultivation sims

 No.144092

>>144088
For the longest time whenever I saw people talking about these "cultivation" novels I assumed they were about farming or some shit, and I wondered why so many people were into slow slice of life novels and why there were so many of them. Only recently did I learn that was not the case.

 No.144145

>>143543
Tbh, I only read the danmei novels. There're quite a lot of omegaverse stories which is pretty cool.
Are there any big manhua? From my quick searches it seems to be similar to webtoons or manhwa - which is definitely not a good sign

 No.144547

File:1698516808696625.png (162.39 KB,496x519)

>>144030
>do chinese teens have their own equivalent of chuuni,
i would say on earth nobody has a more legitimate claim to being the original chuuni of humanity than china does. they take it so far it circles around and becomes actually acceptable, normal, and admiral. remember they have daoism, buddhism, confucianism, plus a lot of superstitions with 2500 years of history to work with. china is a literary nation where it's normal to randomly insert 成语/chengyu like 心旷神怡 and random bits of 2000 year old poetry. culturally they're the only ones on earth who have a religion with 2500 years of history that's rooted in seeking immortality and supernatural powers like daoism. even xi jinping says chengyu during speeches like 粉身碎骨 telling world leaders anybody who attempts to split china will have their bodies torn apart and their bones crushed/they'll die horribly
>cool+cute lolis
look at gacha stuff. of course china uoh's
>games
i tried to post a pastebin link i saw from /v/ i think it's catching the spam filter?
>appeal of chinese 2D media
the biggest appeal to me is daoism themes. simply cause the word 道/dao exists it's worth learning chinese and getting into chinese culture. for other people that's probably not enough motivation and reason though. they've got the largest population of otaku and 2d culture enjoyers on earth hence they made genshin impact and all these other gacha you know cause they love 2d culture. it's difficult for me to try and sell it in a general sense cause people all like different stuff. most people probably just want to dip their toe into it in the most casual sense. to me after reading my first chinese web novel translation there's no going back it's self-evident like breathing it feels strange other people don't get it.

i think i'm doing too much and too disorganized since i made this thread since another person was interested in learning chinese but not everybody wants to go that far instead most others are just looking for something amusing.

since you mentione chuuni i'll post some links

https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1uPpMeXEWt
it starts in english then she begins doing the buddhist sutra pure land rebirth mantra
https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1j54feXEUz
she's singing a cover for the artist doudou who make these new age/folk songs that sound like they're doing sutra or casting curses

https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1RavTeoEuZ
this is a 30 or 40 year old guy reading edgy/philosophical lines from daoist gu/reverend insanity to the background music of air ost
https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1muwGeGEuv
pure unadulterated chuuni it's referencing a meme from the novel reverend insanity
https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV19142147Tv
here's one where it says they aren't worried about offending anybody/revenge as a demon cultivator because if one comes for revenge they'll kill one and if a hundred come they'll kill a hundred and even if the whole world comes for revenge they'll kill the whole world. if they happen to die doing it's because their skill is too poor so it's deserved. this is the purest chuuni in the whole world.


>>144145
https://www.mangatown.com/manga/song_of_the_sky_pacers/
the way they present the chapters is off. don't view the prologue 1.1 or 1.2 heavenly reckoning instead view chapter 1 and then 2 you're fine after that. i don't know why they show those but it's not like that for the chinese version and 1.1+1.2 have heavy spoilers. i can definitely recommend this story by itself.


for me though the more generic manhua was a good way to learn the words with context from visuals so my standard wasn't really strict. manhua trend to start strong and fall off a cliff
https://manhuatop.org/manhua/me-the-heavenly-destined-villain/
here's a more standard cutlivation manhua. i read this novel so the manhua is just visuals and a rehash of the story.



https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iE8FZ8FY-5A i like this series
i guess this is bilibili's english channel on youtube so you can try clicking other stuff they have on it if you feel like it.

 No.144637

>>144547
Personally, I have the most interest over theoretical developments of Daoism and Confucianism, in the west you predominantly get pointed towards the foundational texts but it's like being told to read Plato and Aristotle to get an idea of the European middle ages. It's not wrong, but things changed quite a bit in the ensuing couple milennia, and I understand that what gets called "neo-Confucianism" in the west both doesn't really line up with its infamously rigid reputation and isn't even a term that exists in Chinese tradition to begin with (but that may just be another myth, wiktionary lists its equivalent as 宋明理学).
Of course, literary Chinese isn't going to be easy to parse... but at least I have experience with three thousand or so kanji and their historical background, and it looks like you could give me some solid directions.

 No.144651

I thought about making a daoism thread, what a coincidence

 No.144712

>>144547
>plus a lot of superstitions
You can definitely say that again... My Chinese professor has a lot of old wives' tales she repeats to students with authority! Things like writing in colored ink is bad for your eyes, temperature variations (even by a few degrees!) can cause illness (she's allowed us to leave class early because the computer lab was 68F degrees instead of 72F, and props the door open if it's warmer than 75F and complains), and many other things I'm probably forgetting because she'll casually mention them once and never again.

 No.144737

File:wuji-becomes-taiji.jpg (33.3 KB,680x320)

>>144637
daoism simply is. because it is it's the thing that encompasses so there's a problem when discussing it which is: how do you encompass the thing that encompasses you? words and pictures let us convey ideas, express ourselves, and navigate the world but the world has balance so there's a strength and a weakness. we can make a poor stick figure on a cave wall to represent a horse thus elevating biological life on earth further and opening a new avenue to interact with each other and the world. we can continually progress our ability to create it and convey it until we have an ai make a picture of a horse that looks completely realistic. with all of that though we didn't create a horse or grasp a horse, yet at the same time we did. there's this element of it's there, but it's not there. it's accurate but it's inaccurate. however much we focus and attempt to touch it accurately there's an aspect that's off. so we can say the fixation on a certain approach or writing isn't required, but we can conversely say it works too and structure can help guide you further.

that's talking about it in an abstract sense but we can talk about it in a more concrete sense too. your brain structure and nervous system is unique and varies from other people. the world we see, want, and live in is different. if we imagine we're all standing at different points the requirements for two people to arrive at the same spot varies. due to the nervous system response and brain structure being different the exact words or pictures to allow them to perceive something differs. so something works for others but not for you; so something works for you but not for others. we don't really know the exact condition required to take the step forward so we can only use our nose exploring. i feel being continually exposed to the ideas and themes from different angles and approach lets me get closer to it. this works and it doesn't work. something about it that doesn't work is not everybody is actually here to do it. they don't want to, they don't need to, and they can't and that's fine. not everybody needs to be a farmer to enjoy fruit instead there's this kind of transfer we can do once we develop our understanding enough. so likewise not everybody is meant to contemplate daoism instead the onus is on the people who do to convey the fruit of the achievement to other people. at the same time though people having the foundational knowledge can assist them and having it a sign of personal development and/or achievement (farming or daoism)


the aspect of it's there and not there applies to humans. we can talk about ourselves in terms of how long and to what depth we can do stuff. an example: i can do it, but i can only do it briefly and to a superficial level. it's there and then it's gone.


i personally really feel it in the writing and the characters. it's steeped all over chinese culture in every sort of way you can perceive. western thought really doesn't have this sort of fluid understanding baked into it because for about 1700 years it's been stewing in some sort of absolutism enforced by the sword. postmodernism is basically the mentally retarded western attempt at it that leads to suicide. to be fair though daoism led to emperors being fed mercury+other poisons leading to various societal collapses+mass death as a result. something being there and then not there can lead to death pretty easily lol

 No.144765

>>144737
>how do you encompass the thing that encompasses you?
This is what I'm most interested in, or rather the evolution of the answers that people have tried to answer this question with. What was the difference between the views of Zhuangzi and, say, Zhang Jue? The Daozang is quite long, I imagine the very many ideas it contains are as subject to change as everything else.

In this sense, something really interesting happens with Christianity: depending on the time and place it alternates between fostering extreme humility and equality, versus supporting the powers that be and the usage of great luxury to glorify God. One English preacher in the middle of the 14th century Peasants' Revolt interpreted the beginnings of man in a surprisingly anarchist way:
>When Adam delved and Eve span, Who was then the gentleman? From the beginning all men by nature were created alike, and our bondage or servitude came in by the unjust oppression of naughty men. For if God would have had any bondmen from the beginning, He would have appointed who should be bond, and who free. And therefore I exhort you to consider that now the time is come, appointed to us by God, in which ye may (if ye will) cast off the yoke of bondage, and recover liberty.
As you may imagine, he was executed. Other writers spent the following centuries calling him a demonic bastard and putting forward theological arguments in favor of monarchic rule, like in God Himself being king. I find it to be a particularly interesting episode, and it's the kind of development you can find in books like "The World Turned Upside Down" or papers like "Hirata Atsutane and Western Learning". That's what I'm looking for here, the history of ideas, in this case particularly of Chinese traditions.

 No.144848

>>144547
>simply cause the word 道/dao exists it's worth learning chinese
>Daoism
https://ttc.tasuki.org/display:Code:gff,jhmd,jc,dh,rh/section:meta

a journey of 1000 ri begins with a single step

chapter 47 is my all time favorite, i credit it with pulling me out of neetdom and getting a glimpse of kenshou / satori (yes i know these are buddhist terms but still) / episteme if i may sound pretentious

my translation would be: Without exiting your household you may know all under heaven; without peeking through your window you may see heaven's way. He who goes further, he who knows lesser. As such a sage, without carrying out, yet knows, without seeing, yet is enlightened, without doing, yet accomplishes.

>>143764
>中国风
came across this japanese 二胡 player who studied at China's Central Conservatory of Music on a full ride scholarship.

https://www.youtube.com/@KiRiKs2

i'm somewhat decent at reading mandarin though i would struggle to hold a conversation now (went on exchange in china during school). i simply cannot bring myself to be interested in chinese pop culture, drawing a complete blank post-2010s... here are two of my favorite cdrama OSTs of all time

https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1ki4y1d7Ln/ 张芸京-偏爱 (仙剑奇侠传三・Chinese Paladin 3)
https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1hA41157Pe/ 严艺丹-三寸天堂 (步步惊心・Scarlet Heart)


>>144637
>neo-Confucianism
my impression is it's used loosely to refer to anything after 朱熹 - moving from a "a sage should ◯" to "sagehood is an ideal which you may not attain, but nevertheless can and should be strived towards via consistent work / cultivation"


>>144637
>literary Chinese isn't going to be easy to parse

on the contrary literary chinese is fairly formulaic especially all of the pre-Qin stuff

classical chinese (up til tang dynasty stuff like the poet Dù Fǔ) is taught in japan starting in middle school by mechanically reordering the characters after ensuring you can delineate the nouns, verbs, and particles. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kanbun#Example . couple of brief examples here https://www.chuo-tky.ed.jp/~tsukuda-jh/_resources/content/3064/20200422-074214.pdf . A quick search on the chinese internet suggests that a similar approach is done (favoring direct interpretation) https://www.i-learner.edu.hk/zh/2023/01/third-step-of-classical-chinese%EF%BC%9Aclassical-chinese-to-modern-chinese/ . there's no reason you can't do the same in english (post-tang starts to get more mandarin-like in between the mongols and the isolationist ming dynasty because people started using the vernacular in their writing)

automated CC translation into mandarin / jp using the Parts of Speech tagging NLP approach

https://gumble.pw/classical-chinese-translation.html
https://github.com/KoichiYasuoka/UD-Kundoku

i've been working my way through A New Practical Primer of Literary Chinese (Harvard East Asian Monographs) ISBN-13: ‎978-0674022706 it has mandarin, japanese, and korean readings, the commentary is in english

Classical Chinese for Everyone: A Guide for Absolute Beginners is great for getting used to the sentence structure

if you have some awareness of the kanji forms of japanese particles like の → 之 どこ → 何処 いつ → 何時 此れ 其れ ただ → 只・唯, N1 level ones like と言えども・とも かつて → 嘗て 於いて  従う  しかも → 而も it would be a good start and i daresay you can make it through a huge chunk of the analects because they go like "The stable burned. Confucius returned from court. Did not ask about horses, asked about people."

>>143568
>learning Chinese would give me a much better understanding of Japanese

something i noticed is the more chinese i'm exposed to the more i'm aware of how different it is from the way japanese perceive things i.e. when to kunyomi and when to onyomi, there are times when i'm like 星屑 hoshikuzu is such a japanese way to refer to stardust

In 1637, the Korean envoys dispatched to Japan returned to Korea. When King
Injo 仁祖 (1595–1649; r. 1623−1649) asked them about the Japanese literati, the
Chief Envoy Im Kwang 任絖 (1579–1644) replied:

不成文理,詩則尤不好。Lacking in literary flair, the quality of poetry is particularly poor.

Kim Se-ryŏm (金世濂 1593–1646) (1637), the Vice-Envoy likewise answered:

沿路及江戶多有來問者。皆以理氣性情等語爲問。不可以蠻人而忽之 Many people on the way to and from Edo came to ask questions about the Principle, Force, Nature, and Emotion [Neo-Confucianist philosophy] and the like. We should not neglect them and treat them as barbarians.



there are a huge amount of JP loans in *modern* mandarin. Not just 2 character compounds but even native words like 取り消す → 取消 , 手続き → 手續/续 , 組み合わせ → 組合 (zǔ hé).

on one hand there are a number of expressions from middle / classical chinese that are more frequently used in JP than ZH like 忖度 (sontaku), 遠慮 (enryo), etc. to the point where even chinese people associate these qualities with the japanese;

on the flipside there are particles stemming from classical chinese like 「所」 (not in the ところ / "place" sense) which are flexibly used in ZH like 所愿、所知(道)、 whereas in JP you only see it used in fixed archaic compounds like in legalese when you go pay your taxes (所得税)

same goes for 魅了 and 終了 which are borrowed in isolation in JP whereas 了 is one of the first particles you learn on day 1 in mandarin and can be attached to any verb or the end of a sentence

 No.144850

the strangest parts of mandarin to me so far are certain verbs like how the "flower" kanji became the verb for "spend (money)".. https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/花錢 or how 念 also means "read" in some contexts, 点 (dot) also means "to order (food at a restaurant)", "to light up" (点亮), and even "o' clock", 付 also means "to pay" along with the 付ける sense. i guess a lot of these evolved post-tang dynasty because you see similar borrowings in japanese too like 足 foot vs 足りない (insufficiency) or 服薬 (wtf do clothes have to do with meds).

Lack of katakana as a crutch is irritating because I want to contribute to chinese open source but all computing concepts are calqued like process → 進程, thread → 線程, scheduling → 調度 , port → 端口 etc

i'm rambling way too much so i'll excrete my last thoughts

>>144737
>it's steeped all over chinese culture in every sort of way you can perceive. western thought really doesn't have this sort of fluid understanding baked into it because for about 1700 years it's been stewing in some sort of absolutism

the ancient chinese called the Roman Empire 大秦、 literally Big Qin - the same Qin they used for their own dynasty, because they saw similarities that led to prosperity, they didn't go all the way to rome of course but that was what they inferred from what they saw in syria and slightly beyond...

i know i'm preaching to the choir here but i like deductive reasoning, i like socratic inquiry, obviously there are pitfalls like propensity for navel gazing and nihilist thinking. i know "the name that can be named is not the eternal name", sure... but assigning universally agreed upon definitions, progressing from alchemy to chemistry, separating correlation from causation, determinism, that is what i personally like about the west, for it has also taught me to criticize itself...

>>144765
>happens with Christianity: depending on the time and place it alternates between fostering extreme humility and equality, versus supporting the powers that be and the usage of great luxury to glorify God.

a funny contrast can be drawn between this and legalism - in christianity everyone's a sinner / original sin, in legalism everyone's a selfish bastard, but legalism is a very pragmatic, cynical tool even, instead of kantian absolutes given by a god legalism is strikingly similar to modern management techniques.. things similar to KPIs and employing people in such a way that they can act in their own interests or else they will act against you

 No.144923

>>144850
>Lack of katakana as a crutch is irritating
Really? I find it to be precisely the opposite. It is very fun to see how things are phrased in kanji with actual sinic phonemes.
Japanese is extremely irritating with its excessive loanwords in tech (and in some other things too), to the the point that even though I'm proficient I still keep the computer language in english, because if I change it, it's no exaggeration just english but in katakana and I get pissed off. Yes, they are mostly calques so they are not really pure words, but it's way better than just transliterating english in my opinion. Of course, it is more work as a learner.
>the strangest parts of mandarin to me so far are certain verbs like how the "flower" kanji became the verb for "spend (money)"
That is interesting indeed. You can see here in the flower example the east-asian literary view of the flower focused on the ephemerality. The rest make sense if you make enough mental gymnastics. 念う, if you are reading something then you are kind of 念うing it, so you can definitely see the distant connection.

 No.145228

File:forgiveness.png (3.8 MB,1277x3996)

>>144850
>This is what I'm most interested in
it is... probably? to encompass everything i mean. the issue is the price that has to be paid to do it. when i say price it doesn't necessary work in a linear or direct manner and the price isn't necessary restricted to you or me paying it. it might actually be a question of if the collective of humanity/biological life can create the conditions to allow it thus paying the price. daoism pays a lot of attention to causal transfer and causal equilibrium under the mystique and aphorism. that level of understanding requires a lot to acquire it. also, we can say encompass it to what degree? the higher you go the more it requires.

the cultivation novels at first glance seem maybe sloppy but they're all based on daoism/causality involving causal transfer and equilibrium. you need to absorb spiritual energy from the world and it can and does decrease. it requires taking herbs which take decades, millennium, and scaling up to the only existing one ever as they scale with power. sacrifice isn't depicted as just some lowbrow attempt at penance just because god wants it for reasons...don't ask, okay? instead it's about cause and effect binding exist itself. that's why there's a lot of flexibility in whether you do self-sacrifice or sacrifice others. there's always drawbacks and balance. for example if you go around sacrificing others practicing evil methods there's the downside of it having negative influence on your ability to proceed to higher levels due to stuff like being encumbered with negative karma. at the same time it isn't ruled out because the world allows it even if the conditions are strict to reach the highest point. at the same time there's drawbacks to everybody being in union/harmony without conflict too. examples are they're weak to outside force and the lack of friction causes them to develop slower. i said negative karma, but there's stories and depictions of karma whether it's positive or negative having downsides. the act of being entangled with others can have downsides so if even the protagonist has positive relations/karma the connect can cause him to be burned.

it can and does have good/evil absolutism while still retaining the ability to do gray. it can be fluid with black and white inversions. i can just keep writing about different ways it's displayed, but there's something beyond what i see and it's the chinese themselves developing it. in the west we've got like nickland, accelerationism, various throwbacks to this philosopher or that one but there's no creative industry to support it. we don't have 100,000 annual novels written exploring these ideas where people are celebrated for their artistic take on it.

in china they have billion dollar industries supporting the idea of daoism and developing it actively. i've been reading chinese novels for a decade now and seen how they're developing because the authors are learning from each other and readers are contributing. they have tens of millions of people writing and reading these stories while adding their take on it. you know how memes can just spring up and spread around? philosophical ideas are the same. daoism in china is ubiquitous and influences everything. it's not simply dead where people read dead authors instead it's living and breathing. people see daoism as a philosophy and/or religion, but it's also an art. moldbug got some written piece in washington post and this is suppose to be a win cause gen-x after living for almost 60 years finally escaped the heel of continental philosophy, judeo-christianity, and postmodernism in the most meager way lol. we have memes and blogposts for our ideas while they have the best written literature of the 21st century for their ideas about daoism and causality plus entire industries/government backing+support. i feel art and media is the best way to convey these sort of ideas to people instead of telling them to read a dead person, but at the same time china has a culture that honors their ancestors with confucianism so they do read them too. it's hitting the problem from all sides.

i don't really know exactly what i'd recommend. i like the old and new. the dead and the living. the simple and complex. the crass and sophisticated. china has 4 generations that have grown up with 2d culture and daoism influencing them. their gen-x were hooked on 2d culture in the early 90/00's plus reading daoism stuff. this trend never stopped instead their gen-x spread it further and this spread has only increased. it might seem contrived i'm mentioning 2d culture and daoism in the same sentence but on bilibili their https://www.bilibili.com/guochuang page is 80% completely obvious dao reference material and the remaining 20% is still influenced by it. that's why i recommend china and chinese media in a general sense. i don't know exactly what part though instead it's a feeling that keeping an open-mind and playing it by ear is good?


picture is china's answer to western pilpul about tolerance and forgiveness. this kind of thing doesn't require reading philosophy instead some popular media depicting it and humiliating it is enough to shut it down.

 No.145229

File:1702419468763914.jpg (107.05 KB,595x992)

>>144848
47 is my favorite since i first read it but it produced the opposite for effect for me. i didn't really get it or understand how it could work when i first read it. now i get the world really is something you can simply close your eyes and look at. distance and time doesn't matter since causality isn't restricted by them. we're always interacting with the essence of existence so there's no better place than exactly where we're at to do it.

i noticed the songs you linked had violin and piano. do you like the mellow/kinda tranquil upbeat tone? those songs are love songs in a sense. i don't know music speak to accurately express this so i'm just winging it.

the love songs i like are yearning songs that are slightly sad
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UjCiwb8Cs3I 金池《你不爱我》
https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1JY4y1e7NV/
https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1sm411X71g《你不爱我》(song by my favorite vtuber)
https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1ga4y1i7hs/

i like stuff that gives me an energy feeling or has a yearning feeling.

bonus whatever
https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1gv4y1i7i5 bocchi amv mixed with reference from dao of bizzare immortal
https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1G7bcepEba/ yeah. just yeah.

 No.145237

>>144547
thanks for your response
ill think about what you said

 No.145524

File:east asian exchange imageb….png (457.39 KB,1515x853)

>>145228
>in the west we've got like nickland, accelerationism, various throwbacks to this philosopher or that one but there's no creative industry to support it. we don't have 100,000 annual novels written exploring these ideas where people are celebrated for their artistic take on it.
This is, interestingly enough, something the Russians did have in the 19th century. Tolstoy, Gogol, Pushkin, Dostoyevsky, Chekhov, even Chernyshevsky's What Is To Be Done? that deeply impressed the progressive side of things. The intelligentsia of the time put great weight into these things, and were seen as paving the way towards the modernization of Russia, catching up to Europe and finding out whether it belonged with the westerners at all (not too unlike China right now, I suppose). The debate and their public role in it was considered to be incredibly important.
I understand if you can't pick any specific examples due to how pervasive it is, and I appreciate the introduction. I'll have to read up on the phonetic correspondences between Japanese and Mandarin, because at a glace I have no idea how "guochuang" is supposed to be written... though I see it's 国创, same guo as zhongguo. It's a start.
>>144848
>>144850
Lots of notes taken, thank you kindly. Reminds me of this screenshot Anonymous once posted but whose source I was never able to find.
>Lacking in literary flair, the quality of poetry is particularly poor.
This is the kind of banter that always makes me chuckle, especially given in how high regard Japanese poetry is held overseas, mono no aware and all that.

 No.145694

File:gods-10-commandments.jpg (53.1 KB,499x334)

>>145524
i said earlier that in a 3-4 days i'd post some use resources i found. in like 48 hours i will. the reason why it's so delayed is cause i have to spend a 4+ hours looking around for new stuff and a couple more organizing my thoughts after going through a lot of bookmarks. when i started i bought different online courses and heavily focused on pinyin pronunciation as top priority. i was trying to make sure i get it right so i looked at as many different credible resources as possible. there's hindsight though and stuff i learned afterwards. for example in china there's a lot of dialects and people from the countryside so there's apps/course with certificates to help people practice the most clean standard mandarin possible. think of how news reporters get training so the most people possible can understand it's similar. the best app i used for learning how the stuff is pronounced is a chinese app i found that has various course you can buy and even has features like you record your voice then the clip is sent to a person and they analyze it and give you feedback. i downloaded the app off the chinese version of google play store so it's not useful people here. my ability to learn sound is below average so i think it was worth it to put so much focus on proper pronunciation other people probably don't need to do that.

plus there's stuff like ai chat/audio to assist nowadays, but even beyond that i was thinking tiktok is probably a great place to learn mandarin. i'd actually bet $100 tiktok is even though i don't have it installed and haven't ever used it. place like reddit were so terrible when i looked. i think it's probably even worse nowadays where people are actively well poisoning, but i haven't checked yet to see instead it's my gut feeling. in like 48 hours i'll post links. i need rest for now. lots of rest.

 No.145786

File:1576546154507.png (322.41 KB,800x598)

>>145694
I will watch this thread with great interest.

 No.147388

I've read a few Chinese books and I've liked them all so far. The books I've gone through are
>Journey to the West
>Strange Tales From a Chinese Studio
>Tao Te Ching
>Romance of the Three Kingdoms

I've ordered a copy of the Zhuangzhi butterfly book and other writings and I'm going to be reading that when it arrives.
Anything anyone can rec that fits this general theme of older Chinese stuff would be great. Newer stuff would be fine too as long as it has the same sort of feeling. I like the strange mysticism these books have. I grew up mostly only having access to western media but as I get older I am gravitating towards this stuff. It's all alien and different and I love it.

 No.147430

>>145228
Call me dumb, but where is that image from? Looks like an interesting read.

 No.147435

>>145694
Thanks for taking the time to do it. Just found this thread and I've been thinking of starting to learn Mandarin for the past few weeks. Glad there's people interested in Chinese media on this website.

 No.147444

>>147435
>Glad there's people interested in Chinese media on this website.
I'm might be retarded but isn't Chinese essentially the root of most of the culture and mythology for essentially all of East Asia? There's a lot of people that focus just on Japan but to me I like to start things from the source and work my way up rather than just skim the surface of whatever is newest.

 No.147456

>>147430
Me, The Heavenly Destined Villain
found through reverse search

 No.147463

File:(you).gif (2.88 MB,576x384)

>>147456
Thank you




[Return] [Top] [Catalog] [Post a Reply]
Delete Post [ ]

[ home / bans / all ] [ qa / jp / sum ] [ maho ] [ f / ec ] [ b / poll ] [ tv / bann ] [ toggle-new ]