[ home / bans / all ] [ qa / jp ] [ win / xmas ] [ f / ec ] [ b / poll ] [ tv / bann ] [ toggle-new / tab ]

/poll/ - Polling and Honesty

use for asking the community

New Reply

Options
Comment
File
Whitelist Token
Spoiler
Password (For file deletion.)
Markup tags exist for bold, itallics, header, spoiler etc. as listed in " [options] > View Formatting "


[Return] [Bottom] [Catalog]

File:21.jpg (165.6 KB,1280x1787)

 No.2553




[View Responses]

So, the last thread was a bit confusing for people and the idea wasn't fleshed out well enough. This time I propose an actual poll that will decide if /megu/ is brought back or not.

Historical Reference: /megu/ was kissu's first "imagedump board", and a nice place for kissu users to share lewds with each other, at some point vern decided that for reasons to remove it and open /ec/ in its stead.
This is how things have been up to now. Where I have noticed that there still seems to be a desire for sharing lewds with each other across /qa/ (and myself), but no proper outlet for doing so. Which is why I'm proposing a revival of /megu/ with conditions to ensure that it lasts this time. Which would be that it's unarchived and a limited amount of pages so that it's more in line with the spirit of getting in the mood and sharing lewds you've found with Anonymous.

Now, there are two ways in which the revival for /megu/ could go about. One way is that /ec/'s rebranding or re-ruled so that it's the new /megu/. The other way is that /megu/ is split from /ec/ to preserve the unique niche that /ec/ has found itself in while not being redundant in its use.
The way in which this split would work is that /ec/ is reorganized to contain more of the imagedumps across kissu, and according to degrees of lewdity threads would be split from /ec/ into /megu/.

Ones that should be moved with /megu/:
>>>/ec/7850
>>>/ec/4681
>>>/ec/737
Ones that are fine to stay (Although for future replies the more erotic ones may not be allowed):
>>>/ec/203
>>>/ec/803
>>>/ec/3936
And finally, ones that require debate and deliberation on. Maybe a more specific ruleset that accounts for them, or just move them to /megu/ as well:
>>>/ec/34
>>>/ec/1637

Also, I'd like to stress that I believe /ec/ can retain its current image and still be split off into /megu/ without compromising the identity of the board. Please try to keep discussion productive.

 No.2554

I think it should be said that the second option actually is not an indifference vote, but rather it's a vote that you think it's impossible to create megu without causing other problems

 No.2555

But I suppose since the poll was made this way you want to consider indifference and negitivity as the same thing

 No.2556

>>2553
>at some point vern decided that for reasons to remove it and open /ec/ in its stead
What actually were the reasons it was removed originally? Feels like it would be worth addressing that in order to know if it is worth giving a second try.

 No.2557

Voted for /megu/
Was against it since I thought it'd be a pain to split all posts into /ec/ and /megu/, but then I realized you just split the OPs and not individual posts, which made it sound a whole lot doable
/ec/ for the ecchi and the cute, and /megu/ for everything beyond!

 No.2558

File:90859310_p0.jpg (1.01 MB,1240x1754)

>>2555
It pretty much is. Also my personal thoughts on the matter are that the second vote is a vote for laziness and resistance to thinking, because it's hard to visualize how a solution works even though they probably wouldn't be doing any of the planning for how to make a split work.

 No.2560

>>2556
If I have to remove lolicon to feel like the site isn't in trouble I might as well just rework the concept

 No.2561

>>2557
Well, going into the future with /ec/, I think that the individual posts in threads should abide by the atmosphere of the board, but retroactively going into threads and splitting them up by posts is infeasible and not worth the headache. I'd prefer all the sex stuff and extremely explicit photos be kept in /megu/ while the more tame stuff can go in /ec/.

Still trying to figure out whether stuff like >>>/ec/34 and >>>/ec/1637 should be moved or not, and if not how we'd classify these kind of explicit but artistic posts.

 No.2562

File:31bd3a5bdeab4d99fe32e592ed….mp4 (Spoiler Image,2.55 MB,640x576)

For reference: Something that's neither a doujin nor h-game that has no place on kissu currently.

 No.2563

File:7324bcf32f330d74ac29e7f62d….jpg (545.24 KB,1337x2048)

I was going to abstain, but I decided I'm for voting for stasis because I'm selfish and I don't want to see Anonymous's bad fetishes.

I'm content with /ec/ anyways.

 No.2564

File:76242922_p0.jpg (342.49 KB,768x1024)

I think /ec/ is one of kissu's greatest strengths as something that stands unique among English imageboards and serves as an encapsulation of that which is uniquely Japanese- cute and ecchi existing alongside each other.
>One way is that /ec/'s rebranding or re-ruled so that it's the new /megu/
I have to strongly disagree with it disappearing for the sake of a porn board. I can understand splitting some stuff from it, but not most of it. Penetration and corruption and liquids and sex on /megu/, sure, but tasteful or innocent nudity, especially if it's cute, has a place on /ec/. I think the last two threads linked in the OP deserve to stay on /ec/ in this scenario.
If an image can still be enjoyed while in the refractory period then it should stay on /ec/. Stuff that is great for 5 minutes and then "meh" can go on /megu/.

 No.2565

File:C-1668837805230.png (33.35 KB,559x301)

>>2563
You can hide boards from /all/ you know...
Also I'm pretty sure that the existence of /megu/ would actually mean a net reduction in the amount of bad fetish posts on /ec/ given the criteria of what would go to /megu/

 No.2566

>>2564
>Penetration and corruption and liquids and sex on /megu/, sure, but tasteful or innocent nudity, especially if it's cute, has a place on /ec/. I think the last two threads linked in the OP deserve to stay on /ec/ in this scenario.

Yeah, I think most people can probably agree with this, the problem is how to clearly write this as a rule for the board in a way that even the dumbest poster can comprehend...

 No.2567

>>2563
i will make the NTR thread as soon as it's created

 No.2568

>>2564
true, I put a lot of effort into the concept behind the board and what you say is one of the interesting effects that came out of it.

 No.2569

>>2567
kimo

 No.2570

>>2567
Reflexive shitposting and inflammatory baiting makes me not want to use Kissu or IRC. I don't come here to experience the annoying parts of the internet. If I wanted that, I would still be posting on 4chan.

 No.2571

>>2565
/ec/ is just ecchi. There are no bad fetish threads. If people like >>2567 post on /megu/, then there will be bad fetish threads on /megu/.

 No.2572

>>2570
It's fine, that's just me. I only troll on /secret/.
If people will leave the site because of it I would respect that, just as I have my biases towards lolicon

 No.2573

File:186857.gif (1.66 MB,500x281)

>>2572
I too am biased towards lolicon

 No.2574

File:07bbd741b1e2b00e028d9e442a….jpg (71.15 KB,793x1500)

The poll isn't over yet, but I think the results are pretty clear that people are split down the middle. And the reasoning for the against side is pretty clearly that people think reorganizing kissu to accommodate adding /megu/ would be a detriment to the unique culture /ec/ spawned. Thus there really only exists one solution that'll satisfy everyone, adding /megu/ as a secret board. So with that said:

>>>/megu/

 No.2586

>>2574
Good, that way it competes with /secret/ and not /ec/.

 No.2587

>>2586
Now you don't need to worry about getting mad each time you want to see your kissu H!

 No.2588

>>2586
There's like 2 people who really hate /secret/

 No.2589

>>2587
as long as you hide the ntr thread lmao

 No.2594

>>2574
Is there any rules on /megu/? I don't see a sticky. I just want to know if there's anything I shouldn't post before I do.

 No.2595

>>2594
There will be when I get around to it, but it's pretty much /secret/ rules for now.
Also it's a single page board.
We could adjust these things later

 No.2596

>>2595
lolicon NG?

 No.2597

>>2596
it depends on what I consider a loli, but I haven't kicked the scat guy out yet so I guess I'm in a good mood for now.

 No.2598

>>2587
I don't see who's getting mad. I'm going to enjoy using that board every now and again just as I enjoy using /secret/.




[Return] [Top] [Catalog] [Post a Reply]
Delete Post [ ]

[ home / bans / all ] [ qa / jp ] [ win / xmas ] [ f / ec ] [ b / poll ] [ tv / bann ] [ toggle-new / tab ]