>>150951as i see it only 4chan has the volume of traffic to sustain things like little pseudogenerals on /vst/ or /vrpg/ about some minorly popular game. Even if such a community moved away with out the trickle of fresh blood it would become doomed.
I am generally opposed to altchans as i think most of them were formed for bad reasons. I still remember when 7chan was formed purely because a rules sticky was posted on /b/ and people were upset that people were starting to get banned occasionally on /b/ and they felt betrayed because 'anything goes'. Of course i remembered earlier times when people would get randomly banned and so i felt like the entire thing was a bunch of newbies going off to newb somewhere else. Then 8chan was basically politically motivated.
kissu is ok because /qa/ was shut down and the good /qa/ posters needed a place to go. But it moves very slow. something i posted on /f/ here in 2023 is still there
I can also see the purpose of some places like leftypol since as a person who spent a year trying to commiepost on /pol/ it was not very productive, but then trying to commiepost on leftypol is also not very productive.
But is an altchan going to keep starsector general alive? even bigger things like hgg, there is an entire hgg board on an altchan that maintains the coc mod and that board is basically dead, to the point that even when 4chan died hgg2d moved off to a different altchan than the one that already had a whole board for them.
4chan is important, its the big one, its the front door to imageboard culture, the capital city. It might be a huge mess now but its still important if only to host embassies that can direct people to more focused locations. I think it would be a tragedy for 4chan to actually die, we would become like jews wandering around with out a real homeland to anchor us