No.4686
H2O
better than the VN
No.4688
>>4683Shuffle! is the only one I've seen that surpasses its source material.
The Galaxy Angel anime is great too but it's so different from the VN that it barely counts.
No.4689
>>4683I didn't read a lot of VNs but anime adaptations never appealed to me. The only one I watched until the end was the Planetarian one. It was fine but I still preferred the VN.
No.4690
There's just too much lost in adaptation. They're better watched after reading the source material.
No.4691
Amagami and Clannad work well in my opinion for adaptations of route based VNs and they both do it in the exact opposite ways. Amagami uses about 4 episodes for each girl's route, and Clannad mainly uses Nagisa's route as the through line for the entire show with plot points taken from the other routes and adapted into the story. The pros of the Amagami style is allowing each girl their own time to shine with the MC within their own episodes and their own conclusions. With Clannad we get the experience the main ideas and themes wrapped around one romance, but still get the experiences of the other routes without disrupting that.