[s heading]Only the image matters:[/s] A post is 2D when it has a 2D image ONLY. A post is 3D when it has a 3D image ONLY. i.e. a post about the real world is still "2D" so long as it has a 2D image attached. Conversely, a post about an anime, and that o

Name
Options
Comment
File	Or URL:
Whitelist Token

Video Stream Embedding
Advanced Options	Always Noko Always Sage
Video Timestamp
Captcha Type	Captchouli
Spoiler	Unset Spoiler Image NSFW Image
Password	(For file deletion.)
Markup tags exist for bold, itallics, header, spoiler etc. as listed in " [options] > View Formatting "

File:3DWANI_269.png (278.83 KB,847x866)

What makes a post "2D" or "3D"? Anonymous 09/06/24 (Fri) 18:11:39 No.4803

ONLY the image matters
ONLY the content matters
Both matter, but the image matters more
Both matter, but the content matters more
Could go either way (Depends on something else?)
Other option (Reply with explanation)

[View Responses]

Only the image matters:
A post is 2D when it has a 2D image ONLY. A post is 3D when it has a 3D image ONLY.
i.e. a post about the real world is still "2D" so long as it has a 2D image attached. Conversely, a post about an anime, and that only discusses the anime is "3D" if a 3D image is attached.

Only the content matters:
A post is 2D when it talks about 2D things (Anime, manga, video games, etc.). A post is 3D when it talks about 3D things (IRL people, news, outdoors, animals, etc.)
i.e. a post can have a 2D image, but if it the post is about the real world, it is a "3D post." Conversely, a post can have a 3D image, but if the post is about an anime, then it is a "2D post." The classic example is animal videos are typically considered acceptable on "2D" boards.

Both matter, but the image matters more:
A post can be either 2D or 3D depending on the content, but the image matters more.
i.e. a thread about a seiyuu from a particular anime with a 2D image is a 2D thread more often than not, HOWEVER, a thread about a seiyuu from a particular anime with a picture of the seiyuu is a 3D thread more often than not.

Both matter, but the content matters more:
A post can be either 2D or 3D depending on the image, but the content matters more.
i.e. a thread about a particular anime with a picture of a seiyuu is a 2D thread more often than not. A thread about a seiyuu with a screenshot from the anime is a 3D thread more often than not.

Anonymous 09/06/24 (Fri) 18:13:08 No.4804

File:1591551465511.gif (1.1 MB,480x360)

The image makes for an easy and quick distinction.

Anonymous 09/06/24 (Fri) 18:17:29 No.4805

File:tegaki-1725646642818.png (7.05 KB,380x380)

The presence or lack of depth.

Anonymous 09/06/24 (Fri) 18:17:50 No.4806

A 2D post is spanned by 2 independent vectors.
A 3D post is spanned by 3 independent vectors.

Anonymous 09/08/24 (Sun) 05:42:14 No.4888

picked other option
if at least one of the image or the post text is 3D, the post as a whole is 3D

Anonymous 09/30/24 (Mon) 04:20:56 No.4947

Yuru Yuri was written by a 3d woman.

Anonymous 09/30/24 (Mon) 04:33:53 No.4949

>>4947
a work transcends its author

Anonymous 09/30/24 (Mon) 04:37:07 No.4950

>>4949
It still obviously has an author and is a portion of that author manifest in said work.

Anonymous 09/30/24 (Mon) 04:38:18 No.4951

>>4950
how severe did doc say your autism was

Anonymous 09/30/24 (Mon) 04:44:58 No.4952

>>4951
doc said that you are gay and ur mum smells

Anonymous 09/30/24 (Mon) 04:50:47 No.4954

>>4952
damn, this is a breach of privacy.....

Anonymous 09/30/24 (Mon) 22:23:56 No.4973

File:C-1727735032805.png (121.92 KB,570x467)

Anonymous 09/30/24 (Mon) 23:02:01 No.4974

>>4954
ur mum is a breach of privacy

Anonymous 10/01/24 (Tue) 19:10:46 No.4976

I disagree with the way the OP divides 2D/3D.
A thread about a seiyuu is 2D regardless of image.
A thread discussing an aspect of Japanese culture (eg. Shinto) in the abstract could probably pass as 2D if it had a 2D image but not otherwise.
A thread about American politics is definitely 3D even if it has a drawing of Clownpiece attached to it.
A 3D image attached to a post about anime does not make the post as a whole 3D, but neither does the post being about anime automatically make the use of a 3D image acceptable (which it may or may not be, depending on what it is of. But, either way, an equivalent 2D image would usually be preferable).

Anonymous 10/01/24 (Tue) 20:44:49 No.4977

File:real women.jpg (53.06 KB,385x344)

>>4976
>A thread about a seiyuu is 2D regardless of image.
There is a big difference between discussing a seiyuu's acting and discussing the seiyuu themselves.

/poll/ - Polling and Honesty

New Reply